“Which AI should we use?” is now the question we get asked more than any other. It usually comes with an assumption that there is a clever answer involving feature comparisons. There is not. The three main options are all good. The right one for your business depends less on what the tool can do and more on how much new risk and admin you want to take on to use it.
Here is our honest view, and the reasoning behind it, so you can disagree with us if your situation is different.
Our default: Microsoft Copilot
For most businesses we work with, we recommend Microsoft 365 Copilot first. The main reason is security rather than cleverness.
Copilot works inside the Microsoft 365 you have already secured. It uses your existing files, your existing permissions and your existing sign-in. There is no new supplier, no new data agreement to read, and nothing extra to explain to your customers, your insurer or a tender panel. When someone leaves, their Copilot access goes with their Microsoft account, because it is the same account.
It is also one bill. Microsoft sells Business Premium with Copilot as a bundle, which costs less than buying Business Premium and adding Copilot separately. For a small business that already lives in Outlook, Teams and SharePoint, that is a hard combination to argue with.
Where Copilot is weaker: it is at its best when your data is tidy. It shows people whatever they already have access to, so if your permissions are a mess, it will surface the mess. More on that below.
ChatGPT: the best all-rounder
ChatGPT is the tool most people already know, which matters more than it sounds. Staff pick it up quickly, it handles the widest range of everyday tasks, and it is genuinely good at the general “help me think this through” jobs that do not fit neatly inside a Word document.
If your team’s work is varied, or a lot of it happens outside Microsoft 365, ChatGPT Business or Enterprise is a sensible choice. The business versions matter: they belong to your organisation rather than the individual, and OpenAI states it does not use business data to train its models by default. Personal accounts do not give you that.
Claude: strongest for writing and careful analysis
Claude is the one we point people to when the work is writing quality, long documents or careful analysis. If your business produces reports, proposals, policies or anything where the tone and structure have to be right, it tends to come out ahead. It is also strong on more technical and process-heavy work, which is why we use it ourselves for some of that.
Claude Team and Enterprise give you the organisational controls you need. Like ChatGPT, it is a separate supplier with its own data agreement.
The cost nobody puts on the comparison chart
ChatGPT and Claude are excellent tools. Each one also brings a new supplier, a separate data agreement, a separate bill and another licence to manage every time someone joins or leaves. That is not a reason to avoid them. It is a reason to go in with your eyes open, because for a business of twenty people with no IT department, “another licence to manage” is exactly the kind of thing that quietly does not get done. Six months later there are three ex-employees still holding accounts.
This is one of the jobs our Protect & AI package takes off your hands. Whichever tools you choose, we set them up with single sign-on, sensible data-sharing and connector controls, and access handled through the same joiner and leaver process as everything else. We support all three, and we will tell you plainly if one of them suits your team better than our default.
The tool is the easy part
Whatever you pick, three things decide whether AI saves your team time or creates problems, and none of them is the tool.
- Tidy permissions. AI can see what the person can see. An old “Everyone” folder full of HR documents is a minor embarrassment until AI can search it in seconds.
- A policy people know about. What is approved, what must never be pasted in, and what to do when someone wants a new tool.
- A bit of training. How to check what AI tells you, how to handle client data, and how to spot the phishing emails that AI now writes rather well.
Get those right and any of the three tools will do a good job. Skip them and the best tool in the world will just help people make mistakes faster.
What this means for a business with 5 to 50 people
Start with Copilot unless you have a clear reason not to. Add ChatGPT or Claude where a specific team would genuinely benefit, on business accounts, managed properly. Do the permissions and policy work first, not after. And if you are not sure which tool fits which job, that is a normal place to be; most businesses are there.
Your next step
Rather than picking a tool, start with where your team actually loses time. Our free Automation Discovery call is 60 to 90 minutes, remote, and ends with a short list of things worth looking at in more detail, including which AI tool, if any, would help with each. No sales pitch and no obligation. Book your free Discovery call and we will give you a straight answer.
